WASHINGTON — Rising commercial auto liability costs continue to challenge U.S. trucking companies and insurers, increasing the expense of transporting goods across the country. Industry research shows that insurance costs have risen even as reported heavy-duty truck-involved crash rates declined over a recent multiyear period.
The American Transportation Research Institute reported in May 2026 that commercial auto liability insurance premiums rose 18.6% from 2021 to 2024, reaching 10.2 cents per mile. The increase exceeded consumer inflation by 5.4 percentage points during the period.
ATRI also reported that heavy-duty truck-involved crash rates fell 2.6% industry-wide, while per-mile liability losses among survey respondents rose by an average of 33.1%. The figures indicate that the cost of claims, rather than accident frequency alone, can have a substantial effect on insurance expenses.
Commercial vehicle claims can involve significant financial exposure. Serious accidents may result in medical expenses, vehicle damage, legal disputes and lengthy settlement processes. Litigation costs and the size of court awards can also influence the amount insurers ultimately pay.
These expenses affect transportation businesses that already operate with substantial costs for fuel, labor, maintenance and equipment. Higher insurance premiums can reduce margins, particularly for smaller carriers that have limited negotiating power or operate on tight contracts.
Carriers may respond by reviewing routes, investing in driver training, improving vehicle maintenance and adopting safety technology. Dash cameras, telematics and driver-monitoring systems can help businesses understand risk patterns and encourage safer behavior, although they cannot eliminate the possibility of accidents.
Insurers must balance pricing with the need to remain competitive. They examine claims histories, fleet characteristics, operating territories and safety procedures when evaluating risk. Companies with strong safety records may have more opportunities to negotiate favorable terms, depending on the insurer and market conditions.
The American Transportation Research Institute’s findings also highlight the difference between the frequency of accidents and the severity of claims. Even when crashes become less frequent, rising costs per incident can increase the total amount paid by insurers.
The effects can spread through the wider economy. Trucking companies transport food, consumer products, construction materials and industrial supplies. If insurance expenses rise significantly, carriers may seek higher freight rates or reduce investment in fleet expansion.
However, not every carrier faces the same exposure. Fleet size, cargo type, routes, vehicle use and loss history can influence premiums. The effects of legal and regulatory conditions also differ across states.
Industry participants are likely to continue focusing on risk management and claims control as they negotiate coverage. Long-term improvement will depend on safer operations, more predictable claims costs and a competitive insurance market.
Sources: American Transportation Research Institute, “New ATRI Research Analyzes Motor Carrier Responses to Rising Insurance Costs,” May 19, 2026; AM Best, commercial auto liability report, October 19, 2026.

